During times of crisis, Philosophy is not a Luxury

Jeff CarreiraBlog Posts6 Comments

When we face mounting challenges and global crisis like we are now, we are tempted to see philosophy as a luxury item that we can no longer afford. It’s not!  In fact, in the face of overwhelming difficulties philosophy, which is the pursuit of Truth, becomes more important not less.




Because what we believe is true dictates how we act, and how we act creates how the world is. This is a simple, irrefutable, unalterable and somewhat brutal truth that bears repeating. What we believe is true dictates how we act, and how we act creates how the world is.


If you recognize some part of yourself that protests this statement, look at it. It might be insisting that, “My actions are not dictated to me. I do what I want to do. I am a free independent person.”


If you do find this place in yourself, this protesting voice that insists in its independent and unconditioned freedom of choice, you are looking at the hubris of the post-modern self and the root cause of many of the world’s problems.


Most of us believe in our own free agency to a fault. We believe that nothing can dictate our actions to us – not even our own beliefs. What if it isn’t true? What if you were to discover that you could only ever act in accordance with what you believed to be true – that you were a prisoner to your own beliefs and always would be? How would you relate to philosophy and to your quest to examine what is true then?


I would not go so far as to say that there is no freewill.  I would tend to lean in the direction that was explored by America’s first psychologist William James when he discovered that our freedom is not found in our ability to self direct our actions, but in our ability to choose what we believe.  James also recognized that the world we create as a society depends on the truths we share. His words from the essay “The Will to Believe” have something to say to us today:


A social organism of any sort whatever, large or small, is what it is because each member proceeds to his own duty with a trust that the other members will simultaneously do theirs. Wherever a desired result is achieved by the co-operation of many independent persons, its existence as a fact is a pure consequence of the precursive faith in one another of those immediately concerned. A government, an army, a commercial system, a ship, a college, an athletic team, all exist on this condition, without which not only is nothing achieved, but nothing is even attempted.


If we agree that the world is created by the results of our individual and collective actions, and we know that the world needs to change, then we have to discover a new Truth – together. Philosophy, as the pursuit of Truth, is critical and must become a collective endeavor so that we can change the world by changing the way we think about the world.


Times of crisis, especially economic crisis, are certainly times when we do need to focus our attention and our energies. Some things that were important become luxuries that we can no longer afford. Philosophy is not one of these. Now more than ever we have to examine what we believe to be true and why we believe it, so that we can discover higher, deeper and more encompassing truths that will lead to actions that will change the world for the better.

Discover a profound recognition of awakened consciousness with this
FREE 6-part program.
Secrets of Profound Meditation
6 Spiritual Insights That Will Transform Your Life


The Mystery School for a New Paradigm

Members Circle
Ongoing Guidance and Support for Artists of Possibility who want to share their deepest wisdom and live a vibrant and profoundly inspired spiritual life.


6 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
6 Comment authors
BobbyJoannaDanielleBrian Flemingimants Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Notify of

Hi Jeff,
I love the title – it so true. it is so amazing that often the things that seem to be not that important turn out to be most important when you start thinking about them with some depth.
In the context of the crisis we are in you are giving philosophy the importance it deserves in life. And I am fascinated by James’ statement that that our freedom is not found in our ability to self direct our actions, but in our ability to choose what we believe; I think I am becoming a fan of American philosophy :)


William James definition of freedom accords with my experience. When I have examined as if by slow motion, the process of what can appear as a seamless nothingness of thought, choice and action, the nature of freedom is choice. What I choose from an enlightened perspective is a product of an liberated relationship to the nature of what I take to be my being. That is what philosophy can be defined as being about- an investigation of the principles of being . The concept of truth in itself is a paradox: one one hand it depends very much on the… Read more »

Brian Fleming
Brian Fleming

Re: prisoner to your own beliefs

“Did you ever feel tricked,
By the future you picked?”
– Down to the Ground, by Peter Gabriel
from the WALL▪E soundtrack


Right on!
I have always somewhat regretted that I allowed friends and family to influence my decision to study philosophy and to chose something ‘more practical’. What could be more practical than philosophy!? Unfortunately when I did take a few philosophy classes in University, my professors were anything but shining examples of men or women who lived by higher principles and truths. What has happened to the pursuit of philosophy that it no longer inspires our deepest impulse to evolve to the highest truths we discover? Are our hearts and minds so split within us?


Yes I don’t think we can afford the luxury of indulging in philosophy if it is used to pontificate or ‘blow hot air’ about nice ideas without reason, especially in times of crisis. I think you said it when you said that philosophy was the pursuit of truth to bring about change for the better.


I agree that in times of crisis ones higher nature tends to take over and strip away fabrication to reveal a way forward or progress call this truth but I call it one good reason for life to go on.